Mama Foods paid Rs.8.18 crore for plot No. SP-9 at MIA, Alwar, a plot of RIICO land. The Sub-Registrar adopted a value of Rs.12.08 crore for the deed, and the Assessing Officer taxed the gap of Rs.3.90 crore as the firm’s income under Section 56(2)(x). But the firm had not bought the land itself. It had bought the seller’s rights under a 99-year lease granted by RIICO in 1976.
ITAT Jaipur has now decided the Section 56(2)(x) leasehold rights question in the assessee’s favour: the section does not apply to leasehold rights acquired this way, and the entire addition was deleted. The ruling matters to every business that buys a plot in a state industrial estate, because such plots are usually held on long leases from the state corporation rather than owned outright.
Quick Answer
Does Section 56(2)(x) apply when you buy leasehold rights in land below its stamp duty value?According to ITAT Jaipur, no. The Bombay and Karnataka High Courts have taken opposite views on whether the parallel provision, Section 50C, covers leasehold rights. Two ITAT Delhi benches had therefore applied the view favourable to the assessee to Section 56(2)(x). Following them, ITAT Jaipur decided the Section 56(2)(x) leasehold rights issue for the assessee: land acquired by purchasing leasehold rights is outside the section, and an addition of Rs.3,89,98,000 was deleted. The issue is not settled: the Rajasthan High Court and the Supreme Court have not yet ruled on it, and ITAT Mumbai has taken the opposite view.
Case Snapshot
| Case Name | M/s Mama Foods v. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Central Circle, Alwar (ITAT Jaipur, 2026) |
| Citation | ITA No. 1311/JPR/2025 |
| Court / Bench | Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Jaipur “A” Bench |
| Coram | Smt. Annapurna Gupta (Accountant Member) & Shri T.R. Senthil Kumar (Judicial Member); order authored by Smt. Annapurna Gupta |
| Assessment Year | 2019-20 |
| Date of Hearing | 20 July 2026 |
| Date of Order | 9 October 2026 |
| Key Issue | Whether the difference between the stamp duty value and the price paid for leasehold rights in an industrial plot can be taxed under Section 56(2)(x) |
| Outcome | Assessee’s appeal allowed; addition of Rs.3,89,98,000 deleted |
Table of Contents
Legal Issue: The Section 56(2)(x) Leasehold Rights Question
Section 56(2)(x) taxes a person who receives immovable property for less than its stamp duty value. The difference between the stamp duty value and the price paid is treated as that person’s income from other sources. [Para 4 of the order] For AY 2019-20, the addition applied only where the difference exceeded the higher of Rs.50,000 and 5% of the price paid. Here the difference was about 48% of the price, so the tolerance limit made no difference.
Section 56(2)(x) works alongside Section 50C. The two provisions apply the same stamp duty value to the two sides of one transaction:
| Point | Section 50C | Section 56(2)(x) |
|---|---|---|
| Who is taxed | The seller | The buyer |
| Head of income | Capital gains | Income from other sources |
| Trigger | Transfer of a capital asset, being land or building or both, for less than its stamp duty value | Receipt of immovable property, being land or building or both, for less than its stamp duty value |
| Effect | Stamp duty value is treated as the full value of consideration | The shortfall is taxed as the buyer’s income |
Industrial plots allotted by state corporations such as RIICO, MIDC and GIDC are rarely sold outright. The corporation remains the owner, and the allottee holds the plot on a long lease. When the allottee “sells” the plot, what actually passes to the buyer is the transfer of leasehold rights. The question before the Tribunal was whether a buyer of leasehold rights can be taxed under Section 56(2)(x) at all, when the section speaks of receiving “immovable property, being land or building or both”. Courts have split on the same question under Section 50C, so the answer depends on how that conflict is treated. [Para 3 of the order]
Facts of the Case
The plot. On 12 February 1976, RIICO leased plot No. SP-9, MIA, Alwar, to Eicher Goodearth Pvt. Ltd. for 99 years. [Paras 7 and 21 of the order]
The purchase. By a sale deed dated 27 March 2019, the assessee firm, M/s Mama Foods, acquired Eicher’s leasehold rights in the plot for Rs.8,17,94,000. RIICO permitted the transfer of leasehold rights on 24 April 2019. [Paras 4 and 21 of the order]
The addition. The Sub-Registrar II, Alwar, adopted a value of Rs.12,07,92,000 for registration. The Assessing Officer, Central Circle, Alwar, taxed the difference under Section 56(2)(x):
| Item | Amount (Rs.) |
|---|---|
| Stamp duty value adopted by the Sub-Registrar | 12,07,92,000 |
| Price paid under the sale deed | 8,17,94,000 |
| Addition under Section 56(2)(x) | 3,89,98,000 |
The CIT(A)’s order. On 8 August 2025, the CIT(A), Jaipur-4, confirmed the addition. He relied on the Bombay High Court’s ruling in Vidarbha Veneer Industries Ltd. v. ITO, which held that Section 50C applies to a transfer of leasehold rights. He treated Section 50C and Section 56(2)(x) as pari materia.
The CIT(A) also noted four facts: the plot was acquired by a registered sale deed; the seller chose the buyer; the sale was not routed back through RIICO, which only recorded the new lessee’s name; and the rights were substantially perpetual and transferable, akin to ownership. He rejected the assessee’s reliance on Section 54D and on the Wealth-tax Act as irrelevant to Section 56(2)(x). He also refused the plea to refer the valuation to the District Valuation Officer (DVO), holding that the assessee had produced no evidence of having asked the Assessing Officer for such a reference. [Paras 2, 5, 6 and 7 of the order]
Arguments of the Parties
For the Assessee (Sh. P.C. Parwal, CA)
- The Karnataka High Court in V.S. Chandrashekar v. CIT held that Section 50C applies only to land itself, not to rights in land. With two High Courts in conflict, the view favourable to the assessee must be adopted, as the Supreme Court held in CIT v. Vegetable Products Ltd.
- ITAT Delhi, in Rajesh Kumar Sharma and in Neha Gupta, had already held on this conflict that Section 56(2)(x) does not apply to acquisition through a transfer of leasehold rights.
- Vidarbha Veneer turned on the words “transfer of a capital asset” in Section 50C and the phrase “held by an assessee” in Section 2(14). Section 56(2)(x) instead taxes the “receipt” of immovable property, which is a different concept.
- Where Parliament wanted rights in land covered, it said so expressly, as in Section 54D (“any right in land or building”) and Section 269UA (transfer by way of lease).
- Alternatively, since the assessee disputed the stamp duty value, the valuation should have been referred to the DVO. Relying on Sunil Kumar Agarwal v. CIT (Cal) and Jaykishan Parchani v. ITO (ITAT Indore), counsel argued that an objection to the valuation can be taken even at the appellate stage.
For the Revenue (Sh. Anand Swaroop, CIT-DR)
- The Bombay High Court’s ruling in Vidarbha Veneer applied squarely, and the CIT(A) was right to follow it.
- There was no reason to confine the words “receives any immovable property” in Section 56(2)(x) to ownership and exclude leasehold rights.
- In substance, the transaction was a sale of land: a registered deed, perpetual and transferable rights, and RIICO only recording the new lessee.
- The assessee never disputed the stamp duty value before the Assessing Officer, so no reference to the DVO was required.
Court/Tribunal’s Decision
Allowing the assessee’s appeal and deleting the addition of Rs.3,89,98,000, the Tribunal held:
(i) That, following ITAT Delhi in Rajesh Kumar Sharma and Neha Gupta, which applied the view favourable to the assessee in the face of conflicting Bombay and Karnataka High Court rulings, Section 56(2)(x) does not apply to land acquired by purchasing leasehold rights. [Paras 16, 17 and 19 of the order]
(ii) That those decisions had already held Sections 50C and 56(2)(x) to be pari materia. [Para 20 of the order]
(iii) That the Revenue had pointed out no distinguishing fact and no ruling of the jurisdictional High Court or the Supreme Court in its favour. [Para 18 of the order]
(iv) That the plea that the transaction was in substance a sale of land was of no consequence, since the assessee had undisputedly acquired only leasehold rights. [Para 21 of the order]
Reasoning Behind the Decision
1. Why the CIT(A) upheld the addition. In Vidarbha Veneer Industries Ltd. v. ITO [2025] 174 taxmann.com 223 / (2026) 484 ITR 132 (Bom), the Bombay High Court read Section 50C with the definition of “capital asset” in Section 2(14). That definition covers property “held by an assessee”, not property “owned by an assessee”. The High Court therefore held that it does not matter whether land is held as freehold or leasehold, and that an assignment of a long lease attracts Section 50C. The CIT(A) applied the same logic to Section 56(2)(x). [Paras 5, 7 and 9 of the order]
2. The High Courts disagree. The Karnataka High Court took the opposite view in V.S. Chandrashekar v. CIT [2021] 129 taxmann.com 273 (Kar), holding that Section 50C applies only to land or building and not to leasehold rights in them. Neither High Court has jurisdiction over Rajasthan, so neither ruling binds ITAT Jaipur, and the Revenue could not cite any ruling of the Rajasthan High Court. [Paras 8, 16 and 18 of the order]
3. The view favourable to the assessee prevails. The assessee’s counsel relied on CIT v. Vegetable Products Ltd. [1973] 88 ITR 192 (SC), where the Supreme Court held that where a taxing provision is reasonably capable of two interpretations, the one favourable to the assessee should be adopted. ITAT Delhi had applied this rule in Rajesh Kumar Sharma v. CIT(A) (ITA No. 1785/Del/2025, order dated 29 September 2025) and in Neha Gupta v. ITO [2025] 179 taxmann.com 567 (Delhi Trib), dated 17 October 2025. Both noted the conflict between the Bombay and Karnataka High Courts and held that acquiring property through a transfer of leasehold rights does not attract the deeming provision.
ITAT Jaipur held that these decisions applied squarely and followed them. [Paras 8, 16, 17 and 19 of the order]
4. Sections 50C and 56(2)(x) are treated alike. Both sides argued whether the two sections are pari materia. The Tribunal did not reopen the question, because the Delhi benches had already held that they are. The practical result is that the High Court conflict on Section 50C leasehold rights carries over to Section 56(2)(x). The assessee’s further argument, that “receives” in Section 56(2)(x) is narrower than “transfer” in Section 50C and that Sections 54D and 269UA show Parliament names rights in land when it wants to, was recorded but not separately decided. [Paras 9, 10, 11 and 20 of the order]
5. The Revenue had no answer. The Departmental Representative did not show how the Delhi rulings differed on facts, and cited no ruling of the Rajasthan High Court or the Supreme Court supporting the addition. The Tribunal recorded this before holding that the Delhi rulings applied squarely to the case. [Paras 18 and 19 of the order]
6. Substance did not change the legal character. The CIT(A) and the Revenue had treated the long, transferable lease as, in substance, a sale of land. The Tribunal held this contention to be of no consequence. The undisputed record showed a 99-year RIICO lease of 12 February 1976, a transfer of leasehold rights on 27 March 2019, and RIICO’s permission for that transfer on 24 April 2019. What the assessee received was leasehold rights alone. [Para 21 of the order]
7. The valuation ground was not reached. The assessee had argued, in the alternative, that the stamp duty value should have been referred to the DVO. Once the addition was deleted on the main ground, this question did not need a decision, and the Tribunal gave none. [Paras 13 to 15 and 22 of the order]
Key Legal Principle
Where non-jurisdictional High Courts have taken conflicting views on whether a deeming provision covers a transaction, the Tribunal should adopt the view favourable to the assessee, following the Supreme Court in Vegetable Products. Applying that rule to Section 56(2)(x) leasehold rights cases, ITAT Jaipur held that a buyer who acquires leasehold rights in land, as distinct from the land itself, is not taxed under Section 56(2)(x) on the difference between the stamp duty value and the price paid. A long, transferable lease does not become ownership merely because it resembles ownership in practice.

Practical Implications for Buyers of Industrial Plots
- Check what you actually bought: Read the deed and the corporation’s transfer permission. If the deed transfers leasehold rights from the allottee and the corporation remains the owner, record that clearly in your submissions from the first stage.
- Know your High Court: The favourable-view rule works only where the jurisdictional High Court has not decided the point. If your case falls under the Bombay High Court, Vidarbha Veneer binds the Tribunal on Section 50C, and the argument is much harder.
- Cite the coordinate benches: Rajesh Kumar Sharma, Neha Gupta and now Mama Foods form a line of ITAT rulings on Section 56(2)(x) leasehold rights. Put them before the Assessing Officer and the CIT(A), not only before the Tribunal.
- Keep the valuation challenge alive: Dispute the stamp duty value and ask in writing for a DVO reference at the assessment stage. If the leasehold argument fails at a higher forum, a valuation by the DVO can still reduce the addition.
- Sellers face the mirror issue: The allottee who transfers leasehold rights faces the same question under Section 50C. The Karnataka and Bombay High Court rulings were given on that side of the transaction, so a seller’s position depends on which High Court has jurisdiction.
- Expect an appeal: With Rs.3.90 crore at stake and an open High Court conflict, the Revenue may take this to the Rajasthan High Court. Treat the ruling as strong support, not as final law.
Related Judgments and Limitations
| Case | Forum | Relevance |
|---|---|---|
| Rajesh Kumar Sharma v. CIT(A), ITA No. 1785/Del/2025 (29 September 2025) | ITAT Delhi | Applied the view favourable to the assessee given the High Court conflict; stamp value addition on purchase of leasehold rights deleted; followed here |
| Neha Gupta v. ITO, [2025] 179 taxmann.com 567 (Delhi Trib) (17 October 2025) | ITAT Delhi | Followed Rajesh Kumar Sharma; Section 56(2)(x) not applicable to acquisition through transfer of leasehold rights; followed here |
| CIT v. Vegetable Products Ltd., [1973] 88 ITR 192 (SC) | Supreme Court | Where two reasonable views of a taxing provision exist, the one favourable to the assessee is adopted |
| Vidarbha Veneer Industries Ltd. v. ITO, [2025] 174 taxmann.com 223 (Bom) | Bombay High Court | Section 50C applies to assignment of MIDC leasehold rights, since Section 2(14) covers property “held”, not only “owned”; relied on by the CIT(A) |
| V.S. Chandrashekar v. CIT, [2021] 129 taxmann.com 273 (Kar) | Karnataka High Court | Section 50C does not apply to leasehold rights in land; the contrary view relied on by the assessee |
| Amit Gajanan Khedekar v. ITO, ITA No. 1259/Mum/2026 (28 April 2026) | ITAT Mumbai | Contrary view, not cited in this order: Section 56(2)(x) applies to acquisition of leasehold rights in a MHADA building, as it operates in a wider field than Section 50C; matter sent back for DVO valuation |
| Sunil Kumar Agarwal v. CIT, [2015] 372 ITR 83 (Cal) | Calcutta High Court | Cited on referring the valuation to the DVO; not decided here |
1. It follows coordinate benches. The Tribunal did not independently analyse the wording of Section 56(2)(x). It followed the two ITAT Delhi rulings, which rested on the High Court conflict and the favourable-view rule.
2. The textual argument is still open. The assessee’s strongest independent point, that “receives immovable property” is not the same as “transfer of a capital asset”, and that Sections 54D and 269UA name rights in land expressly, was recorded but not decided. A High Court may decide the issue on that ground either way.
3. ITAT Mumbai disagrees. In Amit Gajanan Khedekar (2026), ITAT Mumbai held that Section 56(2)(x) does apply to leasehold rights. Within the Bombay High Court’s jurisdiction, Vidarbha Veneer also makes the favourable-view argument difficult.
4. Drafting slip in the order. Para 21 refers to the seller as “Eicher Motors”, while the rest of the order names it Eicher Goodearth Pvt. Ltd. The slip does not affect the result.
Frequently Asked Questions
ITAT Jaipur held that it does not, following two ITAT Delhi rulings. Because the Bombay and Karnataka High Courts disagree on whether Section 50C covers leasehold rights, the view favourable to the assessee was applied. ITAT Mumbai has taken the contrary view, so the issue is not settled.
Usually of leasehold rights. The state corporation remains the owner and the allottee holds the plot on a long lease, often 99 years. When the plot is sold, the buyer steps into the remaining lease with the corporation’s permission.
ITAT Delhi held that they are, and ITAT Jaipur followed that view. Section 50C taxes the seller on the stamp duty value, while Section 56(2)(x) taxes the buyer on the shortfall, so a ruling on one is usually applied to the other.
It is not the jurisdictional High Court for Rajasthan, and the Karnataka High Court has taken the opposite view in V.S. Chandrashekar. Faced with that conflict, the Tribunal adopted the view favourable to the assessee.
Yes. Under the third proviso to Section 56(2)(x), the procedure in Section 50C(2) applies, so the Assessing Officer may refer the valuation to a Valuation Officer where the assessee claims that the stamp duty value exceeds the fair market value. In this case the Tribunal did not decide that ground, because it deleted the addition on the leasehold point.
Final Verdict
Based on the above facts and reasoning, ITAT Jaipur allowed the appeal of M/s Mama Foods for AY 2019-20 and deleted the addition of Rs.3,89,98,000 made under Section 56(2)(x). It held that land acquired by purchasing leasehold rights from a RIICO allottee is outside the section, following ITAT Delhi’s application of the favourable-view rule to the Bombay–Karnataka High Court conflict.
In my view, this is a valuable ruling for buyers of industrial plots outside Maharashtra, but it is not the last word. The Tribunal followed coordinate benches rather than deciding the wording of the section, ITAT Mumbai has held the opposite, and a High Court ruling could change the position. Buyers should rely on it while still disputing the valuation and seeking a DVO reference.
Also Read
Corresponding Provisions Under the Income-tax Act, 2025
This case was decided under the Income-tax Act, 1961, for Assessment Year 2019-20. Under the Income-tax Act, 2025, the stamp duty rule for sellers in Section 50C appears in Section 78 (“Special provision for full value of consideration in certain cases”). The rule for buyers in Section 56(2)(x) is reported to sit in Section 92(2)(m), within the provision on income from other sources. Confirm these against the bare Act before relying on them. For other sections, see our Income Tax Act 2025 vs 1961 mapping hub.
Source Judgment: M/s Mama Foods v. ACIT, Central Circle, Alwar (ITAT Jaipur, 2026), ITA No. 1311/JPR/2025, order pronounced 9 October 2026. This order can be looked up on the official ITAT judicial search portal using the ITA number above.
Want the full order copy? Download it here.
Legal Disclaimer: This article is for general informational purposes only and analyses a specific Tribunal order under the Income-tax Act, 1961, as it applied to Assessment Year 2019-20. It is not legal or tax advice, and it does not account for developments after the date of publication or for the specific facts of any reader’s case. The position on leasehold rights differs between benches and High Courts, as noted above. Readers should verify the applicable current position and consult a qualified Chartered Accountant or tax professional before acting on this or any similar matter.







