Section 69: ITAT Deletes ₹30 Lakh On-Money Addition Based on Third-Party Seized Material – Shruti Amar Mehta v. ACIT

Section 69 on-money addition deleted in Shruti Amar Mehta v. ACIT by ITAT Pune
Case at a glance

Case Name: Shruti Amar Mehta (Legal Heir of Late Amar Kantilal Mehta) v. ACIT, Circle-1(1), Pune (ITAT Pune, 2026)

Subject
Section 69 on-money addition: whether cash allegedly paid to a builder for a flat can be taxed on the basis of the builder’s seized diary and an employee’s statement that do not name the buyer
Issue
Where the seized material from a search on the Runwal Group recorded a cash payment of Rs.30,00,000 against the name of another person, could the Assessing Officer add that amount to the deceased assessee’s income as unexplained investment in a flat?
Appeal no.
ITA No. 2683/PUN/2026, order pronounced on 14 October 2026
Forum
ITAT Pune (Shri Manish Borad, Accountant Member, and Shri Vinay Bhamore, Judicial Member)
Assessment year
2020-21
Provisions
Sections 69, 132, 144, 147, 148 and 159, Income-tax Act 1961 (Section 69 corresponds to Section 103, and Sections 147 and 148 to Sections 279 and 280, of the Income-tax Act 2025)
Outcome
In favour of assessee
Background

Facts of the Case

  • The return of income for AY 2020-21 was filed on 30 December 2020, declaring income of Rs.17,71,690.
  • On 6 October 2023, the department searched the Runwal Group under Section 132. The DDIT (Investigation), Mumbai, reported that Shri Amar Kantilal Mehta had bought Flat No. T8-3404 in the group’s project “Forest” and had paid Rs.30,00,000 of the price in cash.
  • Shri Amar Kantilal Mehta had died on 24 May 2023, before the search. His wife and legal heir, Smt. Shruti Amar Mehta, informed the department of his death through the e-filing portal on 23 December 2023.
  • Even so, the Assessing Officer issued the notice under Section 148 on 31 March 2024 in the name of the deceased. No return was filed in response and no reply was given to the notice under Section 142(1).
  • Relying on a blue diary seized from the builder and the statement of Smt. Lucy Roy Choudhary of the Runwal Group, the Assessing Officer completed a best-judgment reassessment under Section 147 read with Section 144 on 28 March 2025. He added Rs.30,00,000 under Section 69 as cash paid for the flat and assessed income at Rs.47,71,690.
  • Before the CIT(A), the legal heir argued that proceedings against a dead person were void and that the addition rested only on third-party material without cross-examination. On 6 March 2026, the CIT(A), NFAC, sent the matter back to the Assessing Officer for a fresh assessment and allowed the appeal for statistical purposes. According to the grounds of appeal, the CIT(A) did not decide the legal ground. The legal heir appealed to the Tribunal.
The timeline

Death, Search and Reassessment: The Key Dates

5 July 2019
Date of the Rs.30,00,000 cash entry in the builder’s seized material, recorded against the name of Kamlesh Navsariwala
30 December 2020
Return for AY 2020-21 filed, declaring Rs.17,71,690
17 September 2021
Flat purchased, according to the legal heir, which falls in AY 2022-23 and not AY 2020-21
24 May 2023
Death of Shri Amar Kantilal Mehta
6 October 2023
Search on the Runwal Group
23 December 2023
Death intimated to the department through the e-filing portal
31 March 2024
Notice under Section 148 issued in the name of the deceased
28 March 2025
Reassessment completed with an addition of Rs.30,00,000 under Section 69
14 October 2026
Tribunal deletes the addition
The ruling

Summary of Decision: What the Tribunal Held

Setting aside the CIT(A)’s order, allowing the appeal on the alternative ground and deleting the addition of Rs.30,00,000, the Tribunal held:

  1. That the Assessing Officer had brought no concrete evidence on record to show that the assessee paid the Rs.30,00,000 recorded in the seized material. [Para 7 of the order]
  2. That, following the coordinate bench decisions in Ashutosh Pandurang Patil v. ITO and Abhishek Shivaji Gade v. ITO, where similar additions for cash allegedly paid to builders were deleted, the addition under Section 69 could not be sustained. [Paras 6 and 7 of the order]
  3. That, as the appeal was allowed on merits, the remaining grounds, including the challenge to the reassessment of a deceased person, had become infructuous and were not decided. [Para 7 of the order]
Why

Reasoning Behind the Decision

  1. The seized entry named someone else. The legal heir pointed out that the seized page relied on in the assessment order did not carry the assessee’s name. It recorded a cash payment of Rs.30,00,000 on 5 July 2019 by one Kamlesh Navsariwala, a person neither known to nor related to the assessee. [Para 6 of the order]
  2. The builder’s employee did not name the assessee either. The legal heir further submitted that, in her statement, Smt. Lucy Roy Choudhary of the Runwal Group said the cash was received from Mr. Kamlesh Navsariwala and never named Shri Amar Kantilal Mehta. On that submission, neither of the two pieces of evidence relied on by the Assessing Officer connected the payment to the assessee. [Para 6 of the order]
  3. The year of the purchase was also questioned. The legal heir also submitted that the flat was bought on 17 September 2021, which falls in AY 2022-23 and not in AY 2020-21. This point is weaker on its own, because the seized entry is dated 5 July 2019, which falls within AY 2020-21, and the Tribunal did not rely on it separately. [Para 6 of the order]
  4. Coordinate benches had deleted similar additions. In Ashutosh Pandurang Patil v. ITO (ITA No. 1432/PUN/2026, order dated 24 June 2026), ITAT Pune deleted an addition for cash allegedly paid as unexplained investment in a property. In Abhishek Shivaji Gade v. ITO (ITA No. 467/PUN/2026, order dated 30 April 2026), it deleted a Rs.2,50,000 addition for a flat bought from the City Group. That addition rested on a retracted statement and an Excel sheet of unclear origin, the buyer was refused cross-examination, and the builder had written to all buyers that no cash was received. Both additions had been made under Section 69A. [Para 6 of the order]
  5. On-money needs evidence linked to the buyer. On-money is cash paid to the builder over and above the price recorded in the agreement. Following the coordinate bench decisions, and in the light of the submissions recorded above, the Tribunal held that the Assessing Officer had failed to bring concrete evidence that the assessee paid the Rs.30,00,000. The result shows that a builder’s diary and an employee’s statement will not sustain a Section 69 on-money addition when neither of them identifies the buyer. [Para 7 of the order]
  6. The legal ground was left open. The legal heir’s main ground was that the notice under Section 148 and the reassessment were void because they were issued in the name of a person who had died, after the death had been reported. Because the addition was deleted on merits, the Tribunal treated the other grounds as infructuous and did not decide them. [Paras 4 and 7 of the order]
Third-party seized diary evidence in Shruti Amar Mehta case involving alleged ₹30 lakh cash payment for property purchase
Practice point

Key Takeaway: How to Defend a Section 69 On-Money Addition

  • Read the seized page itself. In any Section 69 on-money addition, ask for a copy of the exact diary page or sheet relied on. Here the entry was in another person’s name, and that fact was central to the appeal.
  • Check whose name the builder’s staff gave. Obtain the statement relied on and check whether it names you. As this case shows, a statement that names someone else gives the Assessing Officer little support for an addition in your hands.
  • Match the dates with the assessment year. Compare the date of the cash entry, the date of the agreement and the date of registration. An addition under Section 69 belongs to the year in which the investment was made, so an addition made in the wrong year can be challenged.
  • Ask for cross-examination in writing. In Abhishek Shivaji Gade, the refusal of cross-examination was one of the reasons for deleting the addition. Make the request at the assessment stage and keep proof of it.
  • Report a death and insist on notice to the legal heir. Here the death was reported about three months before the notice under Section 148 was issued in the deceased’s name. That jurisdictional objection was raised but not decided, so it remains available in similar cases.
  • The order has drafting slips. It is headed “SMC” although two Members heard it, and its facts paragraph refers to the deceased assessee as “her”. Neither affects the result.
Keep reading

Also Read

Sources: Shruti Amar Mehta v. ACIT, Circle-1(1), Pune, ITA No. 2683/PUN/2026 (ITAT Pune), order pronounced on 14 October 2026, available on the official ITAT judicial search portal. Decisions followed: Ashutosh Pandurang Patil v. ITO, ITA No. 1432/PUN/2026 (ITAT Pune), order dated 24 June 2026; Abhishek Shivaji Gade v. ITO, ITA No. 467/PUN/2026 (ITAT Pune), order dated 30 April 2026.

Want the full order copy? Download it here.

Disclaimer: This summary is for general information only and is not tax or legal advice. Whether an on-money addition can be sustained depends on the seized material and evidence in each case. Verify the current position and consult a qualified professional before acting on it.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *